Charities call High Court judgment a ‘victory for UK environment’


Charities call High Court judgment a ‘victory for UK environment’

The High Court last week ruled that the UK government’s new rules for environmental cases must be changed to protect those taking legal action, which ClientEarth has called a “victory for UK environment”.

Mr Justice Dove said in his judgment on Friday that the “rules would benefit from further clarification in key ways but that they will remain in place”. The government must not make changes to these rules.

The case was launched by charity ClientEarth, which was formed by activist lawyers, alongside Friends of the Earth and RSPB after the UK government has introduced new rules which they say make it “almost impossible to bring an environmental case in the public interest”.

The rules, which were introduced in February 2017, scrapped fixed cost limits on how much individuals and charities had to pay if they lost a case against a public body.

ClientEarth said the Ministry of Justice (MOJ) had resisted calls from environmental charities to “clarify and amend their rules so they would not be used unlawfully, and had – until now – strenuously resisted”.

According to the Guardian Mr Justice Dove, sitting in London, said the charity’s case was “successful in part”, but a further hearing would be necessary to decide “what relief should flow” from his judgment and what orders he should make.

Charities: 'Important victory'

In a statement following the judgment, the three charities said: “Today’s verdict is an important victory in the battle for better access to justice in England and Wales.

“People who bravely stand up for nature by going to court can now do so in the knowledge that, once the costs are fixed, they will not be blindsided by a crippling legal bill they were not expecting and hadn’t budgeted for.

“Another victory from the hearing is that claimants will no longer have to reveal their private financial details in open court, as any hearing about costs protection limits will now take place in private. The MOJ must change its rules to include this, so that they are lawful.”

MoJ: 'High Court supports our approach'

However, the MoJ said that it was pleased that these rules would remain in place.

A spokesperson from the Ministry of Justice said: “We are pleased that the High Court supports our approach to environmental costs protection, which ensures individuals are not expected to pay above their means.

“We will address the issue of private hearings and set out our position in due course.”

The MoJ said that the government made measured adjustments to the regime of costs protection for certain environmental claims in England and Wales in February 2017, following a consultation. It said that the proposals were developed in the light of recent developments in case law, and legal aid remains available where the claimant satisfied the criteria.